0

(1) He seems to have asked her to arrange an interview.
(2) He seems to ask her to arrange an interview.

I understand that the phrase to have asked in the sentence (1) is past tense, which means the act of asking has already occurred. But I am not sure about the tense of the phrase to ask her in the sentence (2).
How should I understand the sentence (2)? He seems, that sounds like present tense but what about the tense of the phrase "to ask her"? Is it present tense or future tense? Could you help me clarify it? Thank you always.

|improve this question
0

If I am not wrong, word association is wrong in the question — so direct answer is not possible.

We have "seems to" ("to seem to") and we have second verb: "have asked" or "ask".

Therefore, we cannot speak about a "past tense infinitive", as infinitive is non-temporal.

Does it make more sense now?

|improve this answer
-1

I must have the same conception of yours.

The first sentence, as you said, implies that the act of asking happened before the act of his seeming, and the second sentence, to me, does not sound very good.

If he is asking her to arrange him an interview, then continuous tense would make the sentence sound better:

He seems to be asking her to arrange him an interview.

The second sentence is not wrong, though it sounds weird.

|improve this answer
  • The second sentence is wrong for the situation unless it is a general statement: He seems to ask her to arrange an interview [every week, every month, all the time, often, never] etc. – Lambie Feb 6 '18 at 15:57
-1

What is that you want to say? If you were observing a conversation between some powerful person and one of his female staff where a name had been mentioned as someone the important person really should not see, and yet from what the important person says, but you cannot be sure, "he seems to ask her to arrange an interview", then there is nothing wrong with the grammar of the sentence you quote.

It will not have escaped your notice that the situation that I had to invent to make sense of that sentence was rather fanciful.

So "non-standard" is not the way to describe it because it could be standard, but only in bizarre circumstances.

|improve this answer
  • powerful person and female staff? Anyway, if you are not sure and you comment on that fact, you would say: He seems to be asking her, He seem to have asked her. A native speaker would never say: He seems to ask her to arrange an interview. The only possible time that would happen might be if you are watching a movie: "What is the character saying in that sequence? He seems to ask her...." etc. – Lambie Feb 6 '18 at 15:55
  • My example specifically mentions observing, as if watching a movie, but it would not have to be. Interesting that all three answers so far have displeased somebody and been downvoted - but not by me. – JeremyC Feb 6 '18 at 17:05
  • 1) is not standard unless it is a general statement, and frankly, I am hard pressed to see it as one. In any case, this is called the bare infinitive and in this: "He seems to ask her to arrange an interview" is odd unless in a discussion re a play or movie etc. Whereas: He seems to ask her on a date every week [and she is loathe to accept]. Don't you think that is useful information? :) – Lambie Feb 6 '18 at 17:16
-1

(1) He seems to have asked her to arrange an interview. Past Tense, OK

BARE INFINITIVE (2) He seems to ask her to arrange an interview. [non-standard present when used for a single situation, which the sentence implies. Unless the sentence say: every week, every day, never, ever, etc. it does't not work.]

Please note: the bare infinitive in 2) suggests, grammatically, a general statement, which would be impossible here.

(2) He seems to be asking her to arrange an interview. [at a present point in time]. Present Continuous used for a one-time thing in the present: once.

(2) He seems to ask her to so many questions during class. [here, a general statement with the bare infinitive works fine.]

|improve this answer

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.