3

Are these sentences natural?

  1. Members of my family have their weddings on Saturdays.

  2. Pete pays a visit to his grandmother once a month. He does it on Saturdays.

  3. I celebrate my birthday on Saturdays.

It is obvious that 'Saturdays' doesn't mean 'every Saturday' or 'almost every Saturday'. But are the sentences natural? Would you consider them incorrect? Or awkward?

1

The way you are phrasing your sentences, they are a bit awkward.

Pete pays a visit to his grandmother once a month. He does it on a Saturday.

"Saturday" should be singular, since he only does it once a month. Otherwise,

Pete pays a visit to his grandmother once a week. He does it on Saturdays.

Your other sentences

Members of my family have their weddings on Saturdays.
I celebrate my birthday on Saturdays.

would be understood to mean

Members of my family have their weddings on a Saturday.
I celebrate my birthday on a Saturday.

1

Your first and third sentences sound natural to me. I'm not sure what I think of your second, but I would probably say "Pete pays a visit to his grandmother once a month, always on a Saturday."

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.