0

Expressions and sources:


Question:

What's the rule, in terms of grammar, for these subjectless questions (i appreciate the link to a grammar book with explanation)

Thank you in advance

  • 1
    I can't say how long ago for sure, but for me, this I believe this usage is rather contemporary. I can't say when people started doing this but today, they do it all the time in two-person conversations. – Lambie Apr 21 '18 at 21:49
  • If "rather contemporary" includes the early 19th century, then yes. books.google.com/… – Tᴚoɯɐuo Apr 22 '18 at 10:08
  • Questions and imperatives often don't really have a "subject" in the same sense that declarative sentences do. – stangdon Apr 22 '18 at 13:28
1

The absence of an explicit subject allows these questions to be asked in a variety of contexts.

Some of those sentences would mean the following if you are directly addressing someone:

Why are you pretending?

Why are you being so serious?

Why don't you go out and make a scene?

Or they could be actual questions about a third person:

Why is she|he pretending? What would cause a person to pretend in that situation?

Why is he|she being so serious. What's going on that he|she would be so serious now? It seems strange for him|her|them to be so serious.

Others could be rhetorical and refer to oneself indirectly as "one":

Why should anyone pretend? Why should I pretend?

Who should one be? Who should I be?

Why should anyone try? Why should I try?

And the most famous one of all:

To be, or not to be?

The verb BE is often omitted. Here the subject is provided by context.

  • For me, these are usually directed at an interlocutor and not about a third person or oneself. – Lambie Apr 21 '18 at 21:48
  • @Lambie: That's just you. I've heard them thousands of times in all three categories. But why try to convince you? – Tᴚoɯɐuo Apr 22 '18 at 10:04
  • I think I see what you mean but would not have expressed as you have done, that's all. It confused me. In conversation, it could refer to a person one is talking about, yes. So, I do agree. Why [should I] pretend otherwise? – Lambie Apr 22 '18 at 15:16
0

I suspect those questions are extracted from the lyrics of songs, which are seldom reliable sources of standard English. Each one is an abbreviated form of a question with a subject, which is thus implied.

Why [should I/we/you] pretend? Why [are you/we] so serious? Why [need/should] one make sense? Who [should I/one try] to be? Why [should/does one] try? Why [do I/you/we] not go out and make a scene?

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.