I'm just asking to make sure. Which one is correct?

  1. The idea arose to me.
  2. The idea arose for me.
  • The idea arose in me ;-) – Jan Doggen Jun 28 '18 at 11:51

Neither of the sentences you suggest is natural: the verb arise cannot be used in this way. The best way to express this would be to use a different verb:

The idea came to me
The idea occurred to me.


I'm afraid your sentences seem a little off.

"Idea arise" is usually followed by prepositions such as: from or in, and an event rather than one's self.

here are a couple of examples:

The idea arose from her husband's newest business venture: arranging customized safaris. [source]

The idea arose from a method used by Matthew LeBreton to preserve dead snakes. [source]

Ms. Kindell said the idea arose in the interest of helping groups defend themselves at audits. [source]

The idea arose after Carey drivers made hundreds of trips for people stranded by the Sept. 11 attacks. [source]

Therefore, I suggest using these instead:

I came up with the idea.

The idea popped up in my head.

The idea formed / emerged in my mind.

The idea flashed into my mind.

The idea hit me.

  • So, if I’m reading this right, “The idea arose in my head” would be okay, too, especially if additional context explains what prompted the idea. – J.R. Jun 28 '18 at 10:41
  • @J.R. No, I don't think it would. As I've explained above, it seems really off to use something like "my mind / head". take a look at the examples. here is more: "The idea arose in response to people's need of drinkable water" – ArashSM79 Jun 28 '18 at 10:49

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.