10

This question already has an answer here:

I was going through an english ACT test and came across this question:

Walker Lee __________ his career in hand forged ironwork at the age of 30.

The possible answers are:

  1. had begun
  2. began

Assuming that Walker Lee is still in ironwork, which is correct and why?

I know there are articles on this concept and I have searched the internet but I am yet to find a concrete explanation.

marked as duplicate by Mari-Lou A, Andrew, Davo, James, Peter Jul 28 '18 at 10:51

This question has been asked before and already has an answer. If those answers do not fully address your question, please ask a new question.

13

The answer should be began.

If it were had begun, then the sentence would need to continue to mention something else that happened at that time.

Such as:

Walker Lee had begun his career in hand-forged ironwork at the age of 30 when meteors started falling from the sky. (Or anything else.)

The use of had begun acts as a link to another event.

Neither of the verb forms is affected by what is actually happening at present, so it doesn't matter if he's still working in ironwork or not.

8

Began is the past tense of begin, while had begun is the past perfect tense. The past tense indicates that something happened, while the past perfect indicates that the thing happened and was completed. It's admittedly a bit odd to talk about the beginning of something being completed, but you can understand it to mean that the actual beginning was sometime even further in the past. So, if you say:

Walker Lee began his career in hand forged ironwork at the age of 30.

then you're talking about the time when his career actually started. The reader will understand that Lee was 30 when he showed up at the forge for his first day of work, and the expectation will be that you're going to continue talking about that time in Lee's story. But if you say:

Walker Lee had begun his career in hand forged ironwork...

then you're talking about a point in time after the career started, and the only reason to talk about that moment is to introduce some new information. For example, you might say:

Walker Lee had begun his career in hand forged ironwork when, at the age of 30, a chance encounter led him to a remarkable innovation.

Here the reader will understand that the career was already started by the time the encounter occurred.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.