0

Is there any difference in meaning among the 3 following sentences?

What I meant was whether that is correct or not.

What I meant was whether that was correct or not.

What I meant was whether that would be correct or not.

If so, an explanation will be great.

Also is the 1st sentence semantically/grammatically correct? (could using "is" & "was" in the same sentence make the meaning of the sentence ambigous here?)

1

A couple of things.

What I was asking was whether...

would be clearer and more idiomatic than what I meant was whether...

There is no rigid rule that absolutely requires the tense of the whether-clause to agree with the past tense in the main clause, though such agreement is good. When it doesn't agree there are consequences.

What I was asking was whether that's correct or not. conversational / colloquial

What I was asking was whether that was correct or not. neutral

What I was asking was whether that would be correct or not. perhaps a tad more polite than neutral

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.