1

There didn't exist computers.

Will there happen similar events in the future?

Are these sentences grammatical or is my mind making stuff up? I haven't been able to find much on the net.

  • To me it sounds like a native Dutch or French person tries to say something in English. "Er waren geen computers." "Il n'y avait pas des ordinateurs." – Michael Paul Aug 24 '18 at 20:39
2

I could be wrong, but I do not think there is anything grammatically wrong with your sentences, however, it is extremely unlikely that a native English speaker would ever phrase a sentence in this way.

For the first sentence, I would expect to hear something like,

'Computers did not exist'.

Even this phrase is very terse and would probably be expanded to something like,

'Computers did not exist at that time',

or

'This was a time before computers were invented'.

For the second sentence, I would expect to hear something like,

'Will similar events happen in the future?'

or

'Is it possible that similar events will happen in the future?'

| improve this answer | |
1

There can be used as a pronoun subject of a sentence (and so before a verb)

Most commonly it is used in the form "there is" or "there are".

However it can also be used with other verbs expressing existence:

In the forest there lived a woodcutter.

There remains the question of the budget.

On the mat there sat a cat.

These are slightly "elevated" in style. For example the first sentence could be expressed "A woodcutter lived in the forest". Using "there" makes this sound like the start of a fairy story.

It is not generally used with other verbs. For example. "To the bus stop there ran James" would be odd. In the correct examples "lived", "remains" and "sat" all include the meaning of "exist in certain place or time", but the verb "run" suggests an action, not existence.

So while "There did not exist computers" may be correct, it is not the common way of expressing this idea.

| improve this answer | |
  • Can verbs such as 'happen' or 'emerge' be used like verbs 'live' or 'sit' in this construction? I think I read something along these lines before. And what sentence construction would be more common for: 'There remains the question of the budget.' Perhaps: 'There is still the question of the budget.'? And as a final confirmation: I take it that in most cases it is more advisable to stick to the usual sentence form. – user7945753 Aug 25 '18 at 3:18
  • You can use them in constructions like "There happens to be an answer to that question". – James K Aug 25 '18 at 12:48

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.