2

Are both of these sentences correct? Does the position of the prepositional phrase matter here?

What do you want to talk with me about?

What do you want to talk about with me?

3
  • 1
    Grammatically no . They mean the same thing- although the second might well be preferable if you wished to emphasise with me . – Ronald Sole Sep 1 '18 at 16:23
  • @Ronald Sole What's wrong with them grammatically? – BoSsYyY Sep 1 '18 at 17:21
  • Nothing is wrong with them. My comment (Grammatically no) was in response to your question of whether the position of the phrase matters. No, it doesn't. The only issue is where you wish to place the emphasis. – Ronald Sole Sep 1 '18 at 22:34
1

OP's two different word sequences are both valid, and it's not really worth exploring whether there could be any nuance of difference between the meanings, but to talk with [someone] is somewhat more "poetic, formal, dated" than the more common talk to someone. That makes OP's first version look slightly "starchy" compared to the second.

But it's equally valid (and much preferred) to use that alternative preposition in OP's example...

What do you want to talk to me about?

There are no hits at all for either of OP's exact examples in Google Books (which optimistically estimates "About 8,370 results" for my alternative, though there are actually only a few dozen if you scroll through).

That difference in "prevalence" probably isn't as significant as those results might suggest though. Most native speakers in most contexts simply wouldn't be likely to notice anything remotely "odd" about the versions that don't turn up in Google Books. I'm going out of my way to make a fine distinction.


EDIT: I though it might be interesting to see how talk to has edged out talk with over time...

enter image description here

2
  • 1
    I don't think it's just a matter of "poetic, formal" register. The choice of prepositions can also mean the difference between a conversation and a lecture. When my boss talks to me, he's giving me work today, or telling me that I'm doing something wrong. When my boss talks with me, he's soliciting advice or having a conversation. (Of course, it's not that cut-and-dried – not at all – but I know I've changed "talk to" to "talk with" when I've wanted to seem less threatening in an email.) – J.R. Sep 1 '18 at 20:36
  • @J.R.: Yeah - I did think about making that point in the answer. We all make that distinction in, say, He always talks to me, not with me. But we can easily make the intended sense even clearer there with He only talks at me, and I think it would be very hard to find many if any examples from my NGram link where that particular distinction was relevant to the choice of preposition. – FumbleFingers Sep 2 '18 at 12:57
0

1) Q: What do you want to talk with me about?

The declarative would be: I want to talk with you about the job.

That's fine. I would say it's somewhat more spoken than the other one.

2) Q: What do you want to talk about with me?

The declarative here would be: I want to talk about the job with you.

The actual order of the words is: talk about something with someone.

To talk with someone about something is not the natural order. But it isn't wrong per se.

Since the verb is to talk about something with someone, I see no reason for putting the about at the end. To me, frankly, it is just less elegant in terms of the actual order of the declarative form, which is the basis for questions, if one is being picky.

When there is no with or to, for that matter, the declarative and interrogative are:

I want to talk about the job. Question: What do you want to talk about?

So, for me: What do you want to talk about with me? is more natural. With plus a pronoun gets added on there. That's why I prefer sentence 2.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.