1. I don't like films that don't have happy endings.

  2. I don't like the films that don't have happy endings.

My grammar book says sentence 1 is the correct answer. But I don't get it. I think the second one should be the answer. Aren't we talking about some specific films?


It certainly doesn't sound like we're talking about any specific films that you and your reader might have in mind. If I say that I don't like red cars, it means that I don't like cars that are red. There is no specificity in that statement whatsoever. All it says is that there are cars of different colors and I just don't happen to like ones that are red. A "that" clause does not necessitate the use of a definite article.


— Do you want to buy a car? But what color do you want your car to be?
— Any color will do except red. I just don't like cars that are red.

— What movies do you not like to watch?
— I don't like to watch movies that are about violence.

I guess, technically speaking, the statements red cars and cars that are red are indeed a little bit more specific than just cars, but they are still no more familiar than cars. Definite articles are used when you have some sort of familiarity or "preknowledge" of the things that you are talking about.

  • Okey so what about this one? "Someone gave me a book about history of modern art" or "Someone gave me a book about the history of modern art" – Talha Özden Sep 4 '18 at 21:07
  • @TalhaÖzden That is specific. But general statements do not take the: I dislike questions about determiners. :) no the. – Lambie Sep 4 '18 at 21:19
  • That's a completely different question, actually. All I can say is that out of the two choices you've got there, the history of modern art is the correct one because in this case that "history" that we're talking about is a very specific thing. – Michael Rybkin Sep 4 '18 at 21:19

Aren't we talking about some specific films?.

Can you (or a party in the conversation) name those specific films?

If not, then you aren't talking about specific films, but films in general. Thus, no article.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.