2

Having forgotten him, he went away.

Is 'having' gerund or participle?

Is 'forgotten' gerund or participle?

And why?

  • "Forgotten" is a participle. The -en forms are never gerunds. This "having" is also a participle. Gerunds (and the phrases they form) do the kinds of job that nouns typically do. Here, "having forgotten him" is a supplemental modifier -- the kind of job that an adverb typically does. – Gary Botnovcan Oct 2 '18 at 14:29
  • What is a compound gerund? – Borhan Ahmed Oct 2 '18 at 17:58
  • Are having and forgotten one participle or each of them individual participles? – Borhan Ahmed Oct 2 '18 at 18:08
  • 1
    "Having" is the kind of verb form that's called a present participle. "Forgotten" is the kind of verb form that's called a past participle. "Him" is the singular objective third-person masculine pronoun. "Having forgotten him" is a complete participial phrase. That's three individual words (two of which happen to be participles) that form one coherent phrase. – Gary Botnovcan Oct 3 '18 at 21:08
  • Also, using two masculine pronouns (him and he) for two different people is not a good idea, especially if the context gives no clues to tell which does what. – amI Oct 4 '18 at 1:16
1

Is 'having' gerund or participle?

For English -ing forms, the traditional distinction is that the term gerund is used for their noun-like uses (referring to the action), whereas the term present participle is used for their adjective-like uses (describing the actor); in your case, having is an example of the latter, so it is a present pariciple. (A similar example with a true adjective would be "Angry at having been forgotten, he […]").

That said, modern grammars of English do not always bother with this distinction, referring to -ing forms as "-ing forms" or gerund-participles or whatnot so as to avoid having to classify each usage in this way.

Is 'forgotten' gerund or participle?

It is a past participle. As applied to English, the term gerund only ever refers to -ing forms (which double as present participles), never to the -ed/-en forms.

| improve this answer | |
0

Gerund phrases and Participial phrases sometimes look alike, but a participial phrase stands on its own, whereas a gerund phrase must be the subject or object of a verb.

Walking down the street, he noticed that there was a lot of litter on the pavement. - participial phrase

Walking down the street is not as safe as it used to be - gerund phrase, subject of is

One of my favourite activities is walking down the street - gerund phrase, object of is

In your sentence, having forgotten him is neither the subject nor the object of a verb, so it is a participial phrase. having is an active/present participle (the bit that makes it a participial phrase), and forgotten is a past participle.

| improve this answer | |
  • "Is" does not take an object. – ruakh Feb 10 '19 at 5:12

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.