0

If I play football since I was eight years old and still I am playing football I should say I have been playing football since I was eight.

But if I started playing football when I was eight and then stopped it 2 years later(now I retire from playing football) I should say I was playing football since I was eight?

So am I correct?

Because I have learned that present perfect continuous is for events that are connected to now but past continuous is finished in the past. (example)

1

If you started playing when you were eight and are still playing:

I have been playing football since I was eight.

If you started playing when you were eight but are no longer playing:

I played football since I was eight.

Although, more idiomatically, this would probably be rephrased as something like:

I played football from the age of eight.

We normally use the simple past for something that is over and done with.


Only if we are talking about a discrete event in the past, generally something that is described as being interrupted, would we use the past continuous:

I was playing football last weekend when I broke my leg.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.