1

I am reading an English text about hypnosis. There is a sentence there as follows:

Just keep the idea of calmness pure and simple grow.

pure and simple are both adjectives not adverbs. So how can they describe a verb ( I mean "grow")?

If this doesn't make sense, can you explain what the text is trying to say, and how it can be written so it's less confusing?

  • Adjectives aside, I don't understand how the verb is supposed to be used. "Keep the idea of calmness grow"? Did they mean "growing"? – snetch Oct 11 '18 at 15:22
  • Your cited text is not syntactically valid (unless we interpret simple grow as a stylised poetic inversion of [you will] grow / become simple, but really that's not credible in this exact context). Effectively, the text isn't "English" - it's just garbage, which can't meaningfully be "analysed". – FumbleFingers Oct 11 '18 at 15:23
  • You failed to tell us that this is a transcription. Transcriptions are very error prone. In Andrew's answer, you can see the verbal pauses and how he has made the sentence grammatical. – Lambie Oct 11 '18 at 16:59
3

The text is from a book on how to hypnotize people. When hypnotizing, you'll often say things in a particular even tone without thinking too much about grammar or word choice. You want to keep the subject relaxed and focused on themselves, and not necessarily on what you are saying.

The line is from a sample script on how to hypnotize a subject by activating certain emotions:

"What would you say the opposite to 'nervous' is? Calm? Contented? Anything else?"

"Calm would be fine."

"Right. We will just keep your mind on the simple idea of being calm then." (Pause). "Calmer and calmer." (Pause.) "Calmer and calmer" (Pause.) "Don't hurry or worry. Just keep the idea of calmness pure and simple grow." (Pause.) "Calmer and calmer." (And continue on these lines for a few minutes or more.) "Now how do you feel?"

As a hypnosis subject, the weird phrasing would probably take me out of any calm state, as I pondered what the hypnotist was trying to say For me, it would have been better to say something like:

"Just let the idea of calmness, pure and simple, grow within you."

Then it's clear "pure and simple" are adjectives that modify "calmness", which the hypnotist wants me to "let grow".

  • Yes, those commas make all the difference. Obviously, the hypnotist is a not a writer and failed to hire an editor... – Lambie Oct 11 '18 at 16:57

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.