1. I died

OR

  1. I have died

which one should be used the moment after dying in a game?

  • 1
    If you want to emphasize that the "death" was recent, you could say something like "I just died." – Canadian Yankee Oct 21 at 17:09
  • 1
    You could also say, "I am dead." – Ron Maupin Oct 21 at 21:58

Either.

In most cases, the choice of a perfect or non-perfect construction is a free one, depending on precisely how the speaker is viewing the events temporally.

"I have died" says that there is a present consequence of the event, whereas "I died" does not: it does not say that there isn't a present consequence, merely that the speaker is choosing to focus on the completed event, rather than on its consequences.

  • what could be the present consequence if I were to say I have died? – user82287 Oct 22 at 5:13
  • First example I can think of is "I have died 5 times in this game, but I will beat it." – trlkly Oct 22 at 5:52
  • is 'I will beat it' a consequence? doesn't consequence mean bad result? – user82287 Oct 22 at 7:20
  • By "consequence", I mean that the speaker is putting some focus on what comes after the action (dying) - i.e. the state of being dead. I am not talking about things that come afterwards. – Colin Fine Oct 22 at 9:32
  • 1
    In the real world, it does imply that, @user82287 (but then, in the real world, nobody is ever in a position to say it). Whether it does or not in the game depends on the rules of that game, I think. – Colin Fine Oct 22 at 15:34

"I died" is common, or even more so, "I'm dead". Related example:

Oh no! I dropped my ice cream!

"I have died" is grammatically correct, and might be more appropriate, but it sounds a bit too formal to use in such a casual context. For whatever reason, the perfect tense adds distance between you and the event, as if you are casually remarking on it rather than experiencing it. Related example:

Oh dear. A tiger has bitten off my leg. What a bother!

Relevant Monty Python (warning: strong language, graphic violence)

  • 2
    Thinking back (a long way back! :) to the school playground, I'm pretty sure in the context of games where players were progressively eliminated / "killed off", the normal "claim" was always You're dead!, and the acknowledgement / status report was always I'm dead. Whoever heard of Bang, bang! You died! – FumbleFingers Oct 21 at 17:32
  • @FumbleFingers: But it's not "bang bang, you've died" either. – Henning Makholm Oct 21 at 21:05
  • Yes @andrew I dropped my phone sounds perfectly normal to me. But I died is intransitive so I thought that might mean at some past time or something. – user82287 Oct 22 at 5:25
  • @user82287 "[Expletive]! I [expletive] died again!" is a pretty common expression in my household :) – Andrew Oct 22 at 5:36

Your Answer

 
discard

By clicking "Post Your Answer", you acknowledge that you have read our updated terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy, and that your continued use of the website is subject to these policies.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.