1

It was used in Crash Course US history. It is at 6 minute and 17 second.

This appears to be photograph of wounded solders in a hospital. I am going to go ahead and call it as being by Mathew Brady.

I cannot quite get the grammar. Could the speaker omit the as being there? I feel the sentence would do fine without it. If am wrong, tell me please why.

  • Personally, I think this use of call is at the very least "slangy" - in any remotely "formal" context I'd expect identify, label, classify, designate, or similar. So far as I can see, the cited example is syntactically equivalent to The witness identified the accused as [being] the man who hit her. In both cases the word being is "optional" - though for some reason it seems more suitable to include it in OP's example, but not in mine. – FumbleFingers Nov 2 '18 at 13:47
  • 1
    "Call" here has the meaning "declare", so the meaning is "I am going to go ahead and declare it as being by Mathew Brady", where "it" is anaphoric to the referent of "this". You could conceivably drop "as being" but there's little point since it would only be treated as a case of ellipsis, with the missing words understood. – BillJ Nov 2 '18 at 13:56
  • I'm going to define this as being an easy question to answer. Others might categorize it as being difficult. – Lambie Nov 2 '18 at 14:28
1

"This appears to be photograph of wounded solders in a hospital. I am going to go ahead and call it as being by Mathew Brady."

Semantic parse:

This usage is spoken: "I'm going to go ahead and call it as being x".

To call something is sports' lingo for what a referee does during a game: to call a foul or to call a play. For example. It has come to mean: to say something about something, to define it.

When looking at a picture or listening to something wherethe person who took the picture or recorded the music or speech, respectively, is not clear, it would be standard AmE spoken English to say: I'm going to call it as being by [some photographer or painter or musician].

This would be used for anything where identifying a person is the issue.

Also, very used: I'm going to call it as I see it. You did steal the money. [Let's say you are having an argument, and you say you did not do something bad. The other person can say that sentence to you.]

Who took the picture? Who is the photography by? Who is the man in the photo? Who is the person recording the message or music?

"I'm going to call it as being John [who took the picture OR made the recording OR who is in the picture].

In this type of case, as being is necessary.

  • I'm going to go ahead and call it as being x"

Go ahead implies there has been hesitation until that point in time.

"As being x" is in line with : x is identified as being [some person or thing].

  • I guess no one is really interested in how this works. Too bad. – Lambie Nov 2 '18 at 16:32
0

(going to go ahead and) call it as being is a verbose and somewhat informal way of saying

venture to say that it is ...

To "call" in this sense means "to make and announce a judgment or determination", as an umpire or referee calls a play in a sport, or the doctor in charge declares time of death when a patient has died.

OK, I'm calling it. Time of death 11:53.

it there can be vaguely referential, referring to the situation at hand.

call it doesn't take a prepositional phrase complement.

I'm going to call it by Matthew Brady NO

  • The question is from a video. I don't think verbosity applies here. "I'm going to call it by Matthew Brady" is missing something without "as being". It also could mean: I'm going to call it "By Michael Brady". And that would mean it is a title, rather than being a photography taken by Michael Brady. – Lambie Nov 2 '18 at 16:35
  • It wouldn't be idiomatic to say "I'm going to call it by Matthew Brady" under any circumstances. That's not how call it is used. – Tᴚoɯɐuo Nov 2 '18 at 16:43
  • I misread your "NO" as I don't post mistakes in block quotes like that. But, in fact, you never even explain the "as being" part, which is actually the question. I answered it and was dv'ed. Go figure..... – Lambie Nov 2 '18 at 16:46
  • Not my downvote, but I think as is an extremely difficult word to explain. – Tᴚoɯɐuo Nov 2 '18 at 16:56
  • With a visual or aural identification situation, you have to have "as being". The issue is not "as". – Lambie Nov 2 '18 at 18:56

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.