1

I have the following sentence that i need to punctuate

Paul's neighbours were terrible so his brother's friends went round to have a word

From my knowledge a semicolon must be used between two independent clauses joined by coordinating conjunction;so this must be the punctuation:

Paul's neighbours were terrible;so his brother's friends went round to have a word

But here in question 6 it says that a comma is needed before the coordinating conjunction hence the sentence is

Paul's neighbours were terrible, so his brother's friends went round to have a word.

Where am i wrong?

  • 1
    Those clauses aren't independent. – Useless Nov 5 '18 at 17:13
  • What's interesting is that the sentence would make more sense (and not be open to debate) if you simply swapped terrible and so: Paul's neighbours were so terrible his brother's friends went round to have a word. – Jason Bassford Nov 6 '18 at 4:03
0

You are wrong that "a semicolon must be used between two independent clauses joined by a coordinating conjunction."

You should know that "two independent clauses can be joined by either a semicolon or a coordinating conjunction."

You should also be aware that it is somewhat odd for grammarians to teach that "a coordinating conjunction separates two independent clauses, but a subordinating conjunction changes the clause that it fronts into a dependent clause." They do so because only a dependent clause is 'adverbial', which allows its position to change relative to the independent clause.

| improve this answer | |

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy