0

Can someone tell me the logic behind it?

For example-

This is the best gift anyone has ever given to me.

I can't figure out why perfect is epecially used in this sentence. On Google there is said that perfect should be used with ever but reason is not clearly given.

1

The word ever means "at any time [during the explicit or implicit time-frame in question]". When there is a restriction upon the time-frame as there is here:

When you were in college, did you ever oversleep and miss an exam?

then ever means "at any time during your college days". Where there is no such restriction, ever means "at any time".

The tense of the question determines the scope of ever.

If the question asks about the future, ever means "at any time in the future":

Will you ever go to Mars?

If the tense is past, the scope of ever is the past:

Did you ever mail that payment? I hope you didn't forget.

The present perfect sets its scope to "at any time in the past or at the present time".

Have you ever wished you were someplace else?
-- Yes. I wish I was someplace else right now.
Other than now?
-- Yes. I have wished I was someplace else on many occasions.

The question as posed includes the present moment. The first answer uses the present, "I wish". The second question, "Other than now?" asks about such a wish in the past. But the reply still uses the present perfect because the speaker is in effect saying "I am a person whose life experience up until the present moment includes instances of wishing I was someplace else".

  • without restrictions, ever means at any point in time till now.so how this allows only present perfect to come and not simple past.i am seriously having an issue with this.every sentence i see in present perfect, i can't justify to myself the reason that why perfect is used, not simple past.in some sentences i cant think why is it like this.why simple past is not used. – Manish Kumar Balayan Dec 8 '18 at 15:34
  • Simple past cannot be used with a time frame that includes (does not exclude) the present. – Tᴚoɯɐuo Dec 8 '18 at 21:44
2

The present perfect is used to describe actions that started in the past and continue into the present. I have been given gifts in the past and now in the present I receive this one. It is the best of all of them (that I have ever been given).

Present perfect

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.