0

There is a series of "Nighty Night" videos for preschoolers about going to bed, e.g. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iqRDEV6BnAU.

All of them begin with the sentence:

Night falls.

I wonder why here Present Simple is used. Why not Present Continuous/Progressive?

Is the following sentence wrong at twilight?

Night is falling.

Improve this question
1

Both are used, but the narrative of this video is written in the present tense, as if the action is happening in the moment. Consider the next sentence:

The little owl is sleepy and gets ready for bed.

This use of the present tense in narrative is not uncommon in children's literature, possibly to teach young readers about things that are common, repetitive, and habitual, or possibly just so they can enjoy it as if they are part of (or at least viewing) the action as it happens.

I found this quote useful:

The present tense is often used in simplified narrative. It has to be simplified, because there is only one tense and the sequence of actions can only be represented by placing them one after another as they happen. source

By convention there's a very different feeling between using the simple present and the present progressive to describe action. The simple present tense tells events as they happen, one after the other, and can be somewhat calm and relaxing. It's often used in things like jokes, where you're waiting to hear what happens next.

A piece of string goes into a bar. The bartender yells, "Hey, we don't serve string here!"

So the string goes back outside, ties himself up, and pulls his ends apart. He then goes back in.

"Didn't I tell you we don't serve string here?!" says the bartender.

"No, I'm a frayed knot," says the string.

The progressive tense, on the other hand, describes what is going on, leaving each event unresolved. It is an uncomfortable way to write narrative, and only rarely used for poetic effect:

See the lights of a neighbor's house
Now she's starting to rise
Take a minute to concentrate
And she opens up her eyes

...

Moving into the universe and she's
Drifting this way and that
Not touching the ground at all and she's
Up above the yard

"And She Was" by the Talking Heads

Even this song uses the past progressive most of the time, alternating with some simple present.

Improve this answer
  • According to English grammar as taught at schools, "as if the action is happening in the moment" and "the action as it happens" suppose even stronger the use of a continuous aspect. So, is this narrative's use of simple present specific for children's literature? Or just a special kind of a narrative, let's call it simple present narrative (independently of the age of the audience)? – Min-Soo Pipefeet Dec 16 '18 at 22:32
  • @Min-SooPipefeet It's possible to use the present tense for narrative -- it's actually a common way to describe action in things like plays or screenplays -- but in things like novels the convention is to use the past tense. Still some stories go against this convention and even use the second person to describe the events, e.g. You go to the door, and open it. As you look outside you see wheat fields in every direction. You feel the wind blowing gently across your face. You walk toward the setting sun and catch the unmistakable scent of freshly-mown hay. – Andrew Dec 17 '18 at 0:12
  • @Min-SooPipefeet for whatever reason it's not convention to use the progressive. That gives a very different feeling, more like someone is forcing you to perform these actions. You are going to the door and opening it. It's weird and uncomfortable. – Andrew Dec 17 '18 at 0:14

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.