1

We can say:

I feel good when I'm hanging out with my friends.

This this the active voice. But why it is also correct to say

Hanging out feels good.

when the passive voice is used? Why the verb feel doesn't change its form to felt:

  • Hanging out is felt good by somebody.
  • Hanging out is being felt good by somebody.

Is it because the verb feel is a special verb? What are the other examples of the verbs that don't change the form when used in active and passive sentences?

  • Many sensational verbs such as 'taste', 'smell' and 'feel' behave this way. – user178049 Dec 27 '18 at 7:47
  • Does the verb feel have two meanings: 1. to experience 2. to give or provide experience to someone? – Alexey Dec 27 '18 at 8:36
  • Yeah. That sounds reasonable to me. – user178049 Dec 27 '18 at 8:46
2

The verb to feel is a special verb.  In your example, it's both ergative and copular

Some languages have a voice that is different from both the active and the passive voices, called the middle voice.  English doesn't, or at least English grammar doesn't have a separate form or structure to mark the middle voice.  Ergative verbs in English use active voice constructions. 

This farmer grows wheat. 
Wheat is grown in the Great Plains. 
Wildflowers grow in my back yard. 

The first sentence above uses the transitive sense of to grow in an active voice construction.  The subject is a semantic actor, and the direct object is a semantic patient.  The second sentence uses the same sense of the verb to grow in a passive voice construction.  There is no actor or agent required (although a prepositional phrase can supply one), and the subject is the patient

The third sentence uses the ergative sense of to grow.  The subject of this sentence isn't simply an actor or a patient.  It's something like actor and patient combined

Suzie smelled the roses. 
The roses smelled wonderful. 

In this pair of sentences we see the transitive and ergative senses of the verb to smell.  In the first, we have subject as actor and direct object as theme.  In the second, we have subject as agent and theme combined and a predicate adjective subject complement. 

Most copular verbs allow either a predicate adjective complement or a predicate nominative complement.  These copular ergatives do not allow predicate nominatives. 

The roses were wonderful.  The roses were a delight.
The roses smelled wonderful.  *The roses smelled a delight.

That last sentence doesn't work with the ergative sense of to smell because "a delight" looks like a direct object instead of a subject complement -- which forces to smell into its transitive rather than ergative sense. 

I feel good. 
Hanging out feels good. 

Both of these have the same grammatical structure as "the roses smelled wonderful."  We have subjects that combine the roles of actor or agent and patient or theme, and a predicate adjective subject complement.  These are both copular ergative structures with predicate adjective subject complements.

Despite the identical grammar, they don't carry the same semantics.  In the first, the subject "I" is able to perceive things.  It makes sense to assign a semantic role of perceiver or experiencer to the subject of the first sentence.  An activity like "hanging out" isn't a sensible perceiver, and we simply assume that someone not mentioned in the sentence experiences the good feeling. 

There is no change in voice between "I feel good" and "hanging out feels good".  There is only a change in what semantic roles those subjects can fill. 

0

It depends how you want to talk about your experience

I feel good when I'm hanging out with my friends. (time shifted)

or

I felt good when I hung out with my friends. (past)

or

Hanging out feels good. (habitual)

  • Thanks, but why the verb feel doesn't change its form? Hanging out is a way of spending a time, it can not fell anything? The person who is hanging out can feel good. – Alexey Dec 27 '18 at 8:22

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.