1

John wanted to have his wife murdered. He looked for someone and found a person who could do it, his name was Paul. John explained how Paul would have to do it, and then answered a question asked by Paul. His answer was "she will be dead, she is not going to speak"

This story is based on a Hitchcok's film "Dial M for murder".

My question is why did John use the "going to" form. Is it because it is an evidence (as "look there are some clouds, it is going to rain") or an intention but when you are dead you have no intention or because it has been planned before.

Could "going to" be replaced by "will"?

1

"Going to [verb]" is simply another construction for future action. It means the same thing as "will [verb]", but is slightly less formal.

"It will rain" and "it is going to rain" mean the same thing.

"She is not going to speak" and "she will not speak" mean the same thing.

The "going to [verb]" construction comes from actually being in the process of moving (i.e. going) somewhere to perform an action, but now it can be used for any future action.

-1

We use "Going to" if we planned something. But If we don't planned anything, we use "will".

Here's example with "going to" sentences.

“It’s going to rain tomorrow”

"They are going to fight"

“I am going to go to work early”

Here's "will" one.

"I’ll do it next week"

  • He just made a decision

“I’ll pay for the food”

  • He just made a decision again, while they eating.

The answer of your question is evidence.

Hope I could help.

  • ok that is what I thought but was not sure because the murdered had also planned before – user5577 Jan 4 at 9:10
  • If he wanted to kill someone, he need a plan :). If you think my answer was helpful, you can verify my answer so other can see it and learn. – sNexy Jan 4 at 10:57
  • so my answer of my question is not because it is an evidence but i because it has been planned before or may be both of them, I will approuve your answer as soon as you have answered to my comment . – user5577 Jan 4 at 11:04
  • If you want to kill someone, do you plan or not? – sNexy Jan 4 at 11:56
  • of course but the reason why John answered using going to is not evidence but the planificatiion he did before if they were no plan it would not use the going to form . Am I right – user5577 Jan 4 at 12:27

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.