3

Can I omit any in the following sentences with uncountable nouns? Do they still sound natural without it?

  • If philosophers were made presidents instead of politicians, there would not be (any) war.

  • If we keep on wasting drinking water like this, in future there will not be (any) drinking water.

Can any teacher or expert please answer this?

1

Those would still be grammatically valid sentences with the omissions of "any", but "any" provides some particular emphasis, so the revised sentences would not necessarily have the exact same meaning.

If philosophers were made presidents instead of politicians, there would not be any war.

In the first example, the sentence without "any" might be understood as "there would not be a war as a direct consequence of the proposed situation." However, the sentence with "any" clearly expresses that no more war will exist at all.

The second example would likely have the same understood meaning with or without "any". However, "any" is used to strongly emphasize the dire situation that a complete lack of drinking water would be.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.