2

This question already has an answer here:

Should I use singular countable nouns or plural countable nouns with no along with the word except?

  • There is no scientist who is as renowned as Einstein except Stephen Hawking.

  • There are no scientists who are as renowned as Einstein except Stephen Hawking.

  • I have no book except this red one.

  • I have no books except this red one.

I know it is more natural to use no with countable plural nouns in general. So we would generally say "There are no scientists in the hall." and "I don't have any books in my house." But when I use no with except the problem arises. Can anyone please explain?

marked as duplicate by Jason Bassford Supports Monica, Nathan Tuggy, Davo, ColleenV Jan 17 at 19:01

This question has been asked before and already has an answer. If those answers do not fully address your question, please ask a new question.

  • I think this is essentially a duplicate of Usage of any with except, but I can't VTC against that one because nobody has upvoted the only answer there (mine! :) My answer does address the relevant issue - specifically contrasting the overwhelming preference for singular in I had no choice but to do as he said, as opposed to the preference for the plural in I had no friends except (him). – FumbleFingers Jan 14 at 14:32
2

When you say "there is no..." then you are making a very definite rule. It is fine to use "except" only if you are making an exception to that rule.

In your first example of scientists - there are probably quite a few scientists that are renowned, or well known - Einstein, Newton, Hubble, to name a few that I know of and I do not work in the field of science. Still, if you intend to declare one scientist the most renowned, then speak in the singular:

There is no scientist who is as renowned as Einstein except Stephen Hawkings.

If on the other hand, you wish to acknowledge that there is more than one renowned scientist then obviously use the plural:

There are few scientists who are as renowned as Einstein, but Stephen Hawkings is among them.

You can see I haven't used "except" in this second example because I am not making an exception to any "rule". I have not said that Einstein is the only renowned scientist, and so Hawkings is not a single exception, he is simply joining the ranks of those renowned scientists I alluded to.

Also, you will notice I have scored out some unnecessary words - you don't need to say "are, are", or "is is".

In your second example about books, it is more a case of what question you are answering. If someone asked you "which books do you have", then you would reply the same way, that you have "no books except this red one". On the other hand, if they asked you "do you have the green book?" there is an assumption you only have one book, so you could answer "I have no book except this red one".

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.