2

Can I omit any in the following sentence? If I do so, Do they sound natural and grammatical? 

  • Yesterday I had my camera with me, but I did not take any photos.

Many grammar books say it is not essential to use any. But I don't quite understand it. Can any teacher or expert please answer this?

1

Although it would be perfectly natural to omit any in a very wide variety of utterances, there is the possibility that its absence might be understood as the speaker's way of hinting at some sort of special circumstances, as a leading statement that will have a follow-up:

I had my mobile phone with me but I didn't take pictures with it.
-- What did you do with it then?
I recorded some bird calls. I could hear them up in the trees but I couldn't see them.

whereas by contrast the same statement with any is more likely to be understood as a simple statement of fact and would not awaken in the listener any curiosity to know more:

I had my mobile phone with me but I didn't take any pictures with it.

That second statement is likely to be understood as "I don't have any pictures to show you." End of story.

So, any and the omission of any can have nuanced meaning in conversation, and there is no crude rule such as 'any' is a non-essential word that can be used or not used at will with no change of meaning.

  • 1
    It also can't be dropped at all in certain constructions: ✘ Pick a card, card. Only with the use of any does the expression make any sense. – Jason Bassford Jan 19 at 10:30

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.