0

"Measuring blood pressure and also heartbeat is/are important for everyone" "is" or "are" ? Why?

I think "is" is correct but I'm not sure.

Is the word "also" important here? Does it add another subject to the sentence?

2

Measuring is important. 

On its own, "measuring" is clearly singular.  The traditional label for this word is gerund -- a non-finite verb form that does the same kinds of jobs that a noun typically does.  Here, it serves as the subject of the sentence, and the verb form that agrees with it is the word "is". 

The clause "measuring are important" would be ungrammatical. 

 

Measuring blood pressure is important. 

Under a traditional analysis, a non-finite verb form does not create a predicate and take a subject.  However, it still can take arguments and adjuncts.  Here, "blood pressure" is the direct object of "measuring", and the gerund phrase "measuring blood pressure" is the complete subject of the sentence. 

This complete gerund phrase is singular, just the same as the gerund on its own. 

 

Measuring blood pressure and heart rate is important. 

Here, there are two noun phrases in the direct object.  The coordination "blood pressure and heart rate" is typically treated as a plural construction, but that doesn't make any difference to this sentence.  A verb must agree with its subject, but there is no rule of agreement about the relationship between a verb and a direct object contained in its subject. 

The clauses "measuring is important", "measuring it is important" and "measuring them is important" are all grammatically sound.  In each, "is" agrees with "measuring".  It doesn't matter whether the direct object exists, and it doesn't matter whether the direct object is singular or plural. 

  • does "also" here not add another subject to the sentence?. It does not mean "measuring blood pressure and also measuring heartbeat" – a.a Jan 19 at 15:06
  • Two things can have similar meanings but different structures. "Measuring blood pressure and also heart rate" is just one gerund phrase. "Measuring blood pressure and also measuring heart rate" is a coordination of two gerund phrases. Consider this: I could say "the gang is coming" or "my friends are coming". Even if "the gang" and "my friends" mean the same thing, we treat "the gang" as singular, but we treat "my friends" as plural. – Gary Botnovcan Jan 19 at 15:24
  • @a.a Your inclination to question this, however, remains correct. If the sentence is changed slightly, it's appropriate to make the verb plural: Measuring blood pressure and measuring heart rate are two important and related activities. Because of the wording added, it now explicitly points to more than one action. The sentence in question is actually ambiguous. It can be taken as answered or in this other way. (If we assume some of that wording was meant but left out.) The answer here is simply the more likely interpretation. – Jason Bassford Jan 19 at 16:10

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.