1

The foreigners mourned with perpetual lamentations for 3 months following Murray's death.

1

Previous answers seem to focus on the literal meaning of "perpetual". But the Oxford dictionary gives this secondary definition:

Occurring repeatedly; so frequent as to seem endless and uninterrupted.

I would say then that your sentence is quite acceptable. As a native British English speaker I can confirm that "perpetual" is used in a looser, hyperbolic way to mean either frequent or persistent, for example:

Stop your perpetual whining

A "perpetual whiner" is quite a common insult (Google it!) and obviously does not mean that someone complains 24 hours a day every day without letup. It just means that they frequently complain.

Likewise, your sentence does not literally mean that their lamenting is expected to go on forever, just that it is so frequent and persistent so as to seem that way.

-1

It does not make sense, as perpetual means "without end, forever" and 3 months is a limited time frame. Perpetual is a stronger word than even "endless", which is a word that would work in this sentence. "Endless lamentations for 3 months..." would imply that they didn't stop their lamentations during these 3 months, but did stop after the 3 months. Perpetual is a word that is exclusively used for things that NEVER end.

  • Endless wouldn't work either. It, too, means without end. It's no different than perpetual. The only words that work here are continuous and continual, depending on if there were interruptions or not. Assuming you want to interpret endless and perpetual in a literal sense. If you don't interpret endless literally, you don't need to interpret perpetual literally either. – Jason Bassford Supports Monica Jan 21 at 6:49
  • Endless literally means without end, but colloquially can be used in a more limited manner. It's implied that it's endless within a certain limit. Perpetual, on the other hand, is typically used in a manner that expressly disallows setting boundaries around it. Think about "Perpetuities" in contracts, which are clauses that are contractually required to be included in FUTURE contracts as well, making them never end even when you'd think it would end. – Richard Winters Jan 21 at 6:52
  • Perpetual can also be used colloquially. Perpetual motion machines and perpetual flames are not really perpetual. And contracts are frequently broken. Just like many marriages seldom actually end in parting in death. – Jason Bassford Supports Monica Jan 21 at 9:17
-1

As pointed by my namesake, Richard, perpetual is not the right word to be used in your phrase.

According to the Cambridge Dictionary

perpetual

continuing forever, or happening all the time

forever

for all time

For all time, during an unlimited time, not just for 3 months. Maybe the word that you are looking for is uninterruptedly

uninterruptedly

in a way that is without any pauses or interruptions

The foreigners mourned uninterruptedly for 3 months following Murray's death

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.