1

The French Foreign Ministry said radar echoes from a satellite put the new debris finding about 2,300 km (1,430 miles) from Perth, without giving a direction or a date.
Source: Reuters – Search area for Malaysian airliner widened after French satellite images

I got the gist of the text above, but still have my doubts if the words “debris” and “finding” are two separate terms or just one term meaning something like “debris founding” or “foundings objects that actually are debris.”

Is the word “echoes” a verb or a noun? My intuition is that it is a noun.

What does the supposedly simple word “put” really mean in this context?

  • 2
    Three questions in one. People get much better and interesting answers when they concentrate on one question at a time rather than just asking for Yes∕no, am I right ? 1) "finding" is a noun, debris qualify the sort of finding done. 2) "echoes" is a noun (the echoes from a radar). 3) "Put" is in this sentence synonym of "situated". – Laure Mar 23 '14 at 14:48
  • 2
    In writing your question you are confused between the verb "find" and the verb "found". A frequent mistake among EFL learners because of proximity between past tense of irregular verb "find" with regular verb "found". – Laure Mar 23 '14 at 14:54
6

This is what I understand.

The French Foreign Ministry said [X], without giving a direction or a date.

This X (what the French Foreign Ministry said) is:

radar echoes from a satellite put the new debris finding about 2,300 km (1,430 miles) from Perth

The subject of the clause is "radar echoes from a satellite", the verb is "put", and the object is "the new debris finding". To summarize, it (the radar echoes) put the finding somewhere. This "somewhere" is "2,300 km (1,430 miles) from Perth".

With that, it's now easier to discuss your concerns.

  1. Are "debris" and "finding" two separate words or one word?

    The phrase "the new debris finding" is a noun phrase. It's a "finding". A "finding" means a result of an investigation. But what is this finding about? It's a finding about the "debris", so we can call it "a debris finding". And because it's the new finding, the noun phrase has become "the new debris finding". In short, you can think of them as two words ("finding" is the headword of the noun phrase, being modified by "debris", which is a noun acting as an adjective), but they are part of one noun phrase--"the new debris finding".

  2. Is the word "echoes" a verb or a noun? (My intuition is that is a noun.)

    This "echoes" is a noun. This noun is "radar echoes". They are "radar echoes from a satellite".

  3. What does the so called simple word "put" here in this context really mean?

    This "put" is a verb (in the past tense). It means "to place something somewhere". In our case, the "radar echoes" placed "the finding" "2,300 km from Perth".

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.