0

When we use the phrase 'other than' before a noun, does it include that person or thing or exclude it? Such as if we say, 'Date is a good thing so other than evening , it should be eaten in the morning.' does it mean:

  1. It should be eaten only in the morning, not in the evening.## OR ##
  2. It should be eaten in the morning as well as in the evening.
1

I suppose it could be used to include, as well as exclude. Really, I think I mostly see it used in introducing or requesting information, often lists. In that case, it's used to say "excluding this obvious answer", or "this answer that has just been mentioned".

Other than Washington D.C., list parts of the USA that are not themselves states, or part of states.

The answers are things like Guam, Puerto Rico, etc.

Other than oranges, name three citrus fruits.

Lime, lemon, grapefruit.

Your example sentence, well, it doesn't read naturally. Even fixing the grammatical number to more normal usage, we get

Dates are good (to eat?/for you?), so other than evening, they should be eaten in the morning.

That isn't a way a native speaker would say it, but if I hear or read that, I would assume that it meant

Dates are good for you, so as well as the evening, they should be eaten in the morning.

It's still not natural, but much more nearly so.

Basically, other than generally means "yes, we acknowledge that this item fits what we're saying or asking, but we want to put it to one side and focus on other things". So it both includes and excludes, depending on how you look at it.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.