2

Shall we capitalize the word after colon?

For example:

The question is: S/shall we capitalize "s" in "shall"?

Another example, https://stats.stackexchange.com/q/91024/1005

For example:

  • E/every marginal distribution of a multivariate normal distribution must be a univariate normal distribution.
  • S/so it is for the multinomial distribution (which is the multivariate generalization of binomial distribution).
  • S/so it is for Dirichlet distribution (which is the multivariate generalization of beta distribution)
  • N/not sure for multivariate t distribution.

(In other words, should each of those individual bullets be capitalized, or not?)

5

It depends on what follows the colon.

  • Is it a list of items? Leave the first item in lower case.
  • Is it more than one sentence? Capitalize all of them.
  • Is it one sentence? It's your option. I'm more prone to use upper-case depending if I want a sharper demarcation between what precedes and follows the colon, and a lower case if I want a smoother flow.

This pretty much echoes the guidance given by sites such as Grammar Girl, CCCF, GrammarBook, UNC Writing Center.

Examples:

  • These three things remain: faith, hope, and love. [list]
  • Everybody wanted to know: What would happen next? Would Batman be saved? [two sentences]
  • All of the clues led to one conclusion: The butler was the one who did it. [single sentence, upper case]
  • The librarian warned the rowdy students: excessive noise would not be tolerated. [single sentence, lower case]

I like the practical guidance one person wrote at the Q-and-A site for the Chicago Manual of Style:

Rules can’t cover every instance. Don’t waste time overthinking: if it’s that hard to determine, it probably doesn’t matter.

1

In some cases, a list such as this punctuated as one sentence, despite the bullet points. This means that every point starts with a lowercase letter, and every line finishes with a comma / semicolon, apart from the final line, which ends with a full stop (or period, as Americans would say).

When writing less formally, or in general, you would forget the layout described above, and every point would start with a capital, and every line would finish with a full stop (period, as Americans would say).

I would say that it mostly comes down to preference. It is likely there is a rule defining how such lists should be formatted, but very few people still consider them relevant. There is no longer a 'right' or 'wrong' way, and it is more likely that the capitalisation would happen.

  • What about the lines before the final line are questions? Shall them be ended with a question mark instead of a semicolon, and shall the first letter of the next line be capitalized? – Tim Mar 26 '14 at 22:27
  • If the statement with the bullet list is a question, all the point would end with a semicolon, and, correct, the final line would end with a question mark. – MMJZ Mar 26 '14 at 22:29

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.