The people said to him, “To-morrow you will be hanged.” It was not very pleasant news, and besides, he had left the tinder-box at the inn. In the morning he could see through the iron grating of the little window how the people were hastening out of the town to see him hanged.

This is a part of the fairy tale "The tinder-box".

At the bold part, what does that "hanged" mean?

  1. who had been already hanged
  2. who was being hanged
  3. who would be hanged
  4. All of the 1,2,3 are possible, depending on the circumstances.

Thanks for your help in advance.

  • Please see the edit to my answer. I clarified what part of speech "hanged" is in your example. – Andrew Mar 6 '19 at 16:48
  • @Andrew I'm sorry. I don't understand your (Edit) part. As far as I know, in the structure of passive form "Subject + Be verb + A + by ~", all A are past participles (p.p.). Am I mistaken? <"to be hanged" is not actually the past participle>, what does it mean? – Fringetos Mar 9 '19 at 14:43
  • Hm. I might be mistaken. I think of the passive form of the verb as something different from the past participle, but I guess I was wrong. I'm going to need to edit my entire answer now. – Andrew Mar 9 '19 at 15:04

In your example sentence "to be hanged" is the infinitive of the passive form of the verb "to hang":

In the morning, the hangman will hang the narrator.
In the morning, the narrator will be hanged (by the hangman).

The people hastened from the town to see the hangman hang him (the narrator).
The people hastened from the town to see him (the narrator) be hanged.

In your example sentence, "to see him hanged" describes the reason why the townspeople are "hastening out of the town" and is essentially timeless. From the perspective of the townspeople, the hanging is in the future, but the entire event could take place in the past, present or future, depending on the rest of the context:

(past) The townspeople streamed from the town to see the man hanged.

(present) The townspeople are streaming from the town to see ...

(future) The townspeople will stream from the town to see ...

If you want to emphasize that the hanging is in the relative future (and therefore still uncertain), you can say something like:

... to see the men who were to be hanged.

If instead you want to say that the townspeople are coming out to see his body after he had been hanged, that's how you would phrase it:

The people streamed from the town to see the men who had been hanged.

Side note: Past participles can also act as adjectives, in this case modifying the narrator who, in the near future, will be a hanged man.

Adjectives by themselves are timeless, so you have to rely on the context to determine the time frame. However, "hanged", like "finished" or "awakened", is a binary state -- which is to say, you can either be hanged or not hanged, but you can't be somewhere in-between. For this reason it's possible to use a participle to write a sentence with your meaning 1:

The cowboy rode silently past the hanged men, away from the town and out into the desert.

or meaning 3:

The cowboy rode silently past the sullen group, who knew that, the next morning, they would all be hanged men.

but not meaning 2. If you want to write about a hanging in progress, use the present progressive:

"Look, they are hanging the men now!" the children called out, as the cowboy rode away from the town and out into the desert.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.