1

Is there is meaning difference if use Is + V1 & Is + V2?

a) This is the room which is share by 5 student.

(Referring to the Present tense fact that 5 student are sharing this room)

b) This is the room which is shared by 5 student.

(Referring as Present passive Passive voice mean room is shared by 5 student)

Help me to understand the difference.

  • 1
    Just to note, native speakers don't generally number the forms of verbs. You can call them by names, or use the examples. This was an understandable question because the examples told us what you meant by the numbered forms. – SamBC Mar 12 at 15:01
  • This numbering system is widely used to teach students english in some countries. v1 indicating present form, v2 past and v3 past perfect. – eefar Mar 12 at 16:16
2

Neither sentence is grammatical. You must use the plural, “students,” when talking about any number of them besides one. And “that” is preferred to “which” in this context. “Share” certainly does not work. You must use the past participle “shared” in this context. If you wanted to change the tense of the sentence, you would change the verb is (the one that precedes “shared”):

Past:

This is the room that was shared by five students.

Present:

This is the room that is shared by five students.

Future:

This is the room that will be shared by five students.

  • would This is the room that is being shared by five students work as well? – Andrew Tobilko Mar 12 at 12:50
  • Sure, that would work for the present also - similar meaning to “is shared”. – Mixolydian Mar 12 at 13:15
0

This is the room which is share by 5 students.

This is grammatically incorrect.

This is the room which is shared by 5 students.

This one is correct, moreover, here shared is not the past form of share, shared is past participle here.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.