Is the following use of "with which to" correct?
Algae will deplete the supply of oxygen with which to sustain fish in the river.
I'd appreciate your help.
English Language Learners Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for speakers of other languages learning English. It only takes a minute to sign up.
Sign up to join this communityIs the following use of "with which to" correct?
Algae will deplete the supply of oxygen with which to sustain fish in the river.
I'd appreciate your help.
No, this sentence is not quite correct:
Algae will deplete the supply of oxygen with which to sustain fish in the river.
You would use "with which to" if the subject of your sentence (the algae) was using the object (oxygen) to do something, for example:
John has a supply of fish food with which to feed the fish.
This is correct because John will be feeding the fish. The above is essentially the same as saying:
John feeds the fish with his supply of fish food.
The "doing" doesn't always have to be by a named subject in your sentence, but "with which to" always implies action on somebody's part. However, in your sentence, the algae is actually hampering the use of the oxygen, not using it. In fact the oxygen in the river sustains the fish as an act of nature, not with any intent. For that reason I don't feel this expression is appropriate.
I think your sentence should read:
Algae will deplete the supply of oxygen which sustains fish in the river.