0

Are there any differences between the following sentences?

  • People who live on their own are often feeling lonely.
  • People living on their own are often feeling lonely.

Other examples:

  • Those who go to the gym many times a week feel invigorated at work.
  • Those going to the gym many times a week feel invigorated at work.
0

[1] People [who live in on their own] are often feeling lonely.

[2] People [living on their own] are often feeling lonely.

Syntactically, both bracketed clauses modify "people". The difference is that in [1] it's a relative clause, in [2] a gerund-participial clause.

Semantically, they are very similar and there's little to choose between them, though statistics show that [2] is more common than [1].

The same applies syntactically to your other two examples, though semantically it's the relative clause that is the more common.

2
  • Don't know why someone down-voted your explanation. Thanks anyway! I think you explained it clearly. Basically, they're both okay but one is more common than the other, right?
    – pilti
    Apr 1 '19 at 16:20
  • @pilti Yes: that's correct.
    – BillJ
    Apr 1 '19 at 16:32

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .