0

I looked on Google and there's rarely anyone ever using the expression elect someone to x, as in choose someone to do something, so I was wondering if it was grammatical in any way.

For example:

They elected him to pilot the aircraft, which was in free fall, because he had the most experience within our group.

  • They picked or selected him. elect, not here. – Lambie Apr 4 at 22:28
  • Why would elect be wrong though? If they have a vote, shouldn't it be elect? – frbsfok Apr 4 at 22:29
  • 1
    When an airplane is falling, there's no voting. Elect is for elections. Elections take time.... – Lambie Apr 4 at 22:33
2

The example is a little silly, because people are unlikely to vote in that situation. Elect, in that sort of context, suggests that they were chosen through a vote.

However, the general point of electing people to do something is fine. Google Ngram Viewer shows a lot of "elected him to" phrases, and some of them have verbs as the next word. Of course, if it's electing someone to do a job, to fill a position, you see "elected him as" a lot, too. It's the fact of when people would vote that does a lot to determine what verb you might see after "elected him to".

Now, elect can be a formal way to say choose, but not in order to say "choose to do a job" unless that choice was by voting. For example, "I elected to stay home that day" means I chose to stay at home that day, and it's a bit formal and stilted but perfectly normal. But "I elect you to do this job" doesn't make sense unless you're suggesting you did it by voting.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.