0

I am a English Learner. I am very bad regarding tense. Somewhere in the youtube in the comment section I got a comment about a topic How many match box have you used? . As per my knowledge the question asked depend upon Present perfect tense.

As per the definition of Present perfect tense , present perfect tense use when the activity which occur in the past but the the timeline is unknown.

So my question is that can we represent the above question in simple past tense? Is it necessary that always ask question in present perfect tense?

  • There is nothing at all wrong with the tense of that sentence. (Barring further context that hasn't been given.) What is wrong with it is that it should be matchboxes (or match boxes, depending on how you form the noun). It's plural, not singular. – Jason Bassford May 1 at 5:48
3

Saswati. I'll just deal with a grammatical error in your question first: "box" is countable, so "how many" needs a plural noun phrase: "How many match boxes".

Now, to get on to your question about tenses. The use of the perfect in English is difficult for learners, there is no doubt.

In most cases, both forms (present perfect, and simple past) are possible: the difference usually lies not in the circumstances being described, but just in how the speaker is choosing to relate to them.

If you say

How many matchboxes did you use?

you are regarding the event of using the matchboxes as complete and finished. If you say

How many matchboxes have you used?

you are regarding it as having some present relevance.

What makes it difficult, is that the precise nature of this present relevance is not expressed, and it could be different things. It could be that you are still doing things with matchboxes, and might use some more after this. It could be that you have only just finished using the matchboxes, and the speaker is regarding the use as continuing to the present. It could be that you are looking at the construction made out of matchboxes, and so the "present relevance" is that the result of the using is here before you.

But in all those circumstances, except perhaps the first, you could equally choose to ask "How many matchboxes did you use?", presenting the activity as complete for the purposes of the question.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.