0

This is Carnegie's defense of competition:

It is best for the race, because it insures the survival of the fittest in every department.

Which one is the meaning of the part that I've emboldened?

1) it insures, in every aspect, the survival of the fittest

2) it insures the survival of the individuals who are in every aspect the fittest

I've assumed that 'department' means a specified aspect or quality here.

2

It could mean either of these, or quite possibly both at once. I would need to read Carnegie's actual writing for context to be able to tell. The phrase "The survival of the fittest" is of course a very standard phrase used in describing the result of Darwinian evolution, also known as 'natural selection". It is often misunderstood and misused, and i rather suspect, from what I know of Carnegie's opinions, that he was misusing it, but I am not at all sure.

1

"Survival of the fittest" refers to Charles Darwin's theory of evolution through natural selection in his famous work "On the Origin of Species", published in 1859. By 1889, when Andrew Carnegie published "The Gospel of Wealth", Darwin's theory had become used as justification for a number of other (pseudo-scientific) theories. Key among these was the idea of Social Darwinism, which some used to argue that the "fittest" in society become the most financially successful.

This aspect of Social Darwinism almost certainly underlies Carnegie's philosophy, as he argues that the wealthy have "superior wisdom, experience, and the ability to administer [wealth]", whereas the poor are "foolish, impudent, and unskilled". He argues that the rich must guide the poor, who are "unfit" to guide themselves.

Carnegie embraces competition as the primary means to distinguish the "fit" from the "unfit", via (we can assume) the acquisition of wealth. Those who are "fit" will get rich. Those who are "unfit" will remain poor. While some win and some lose, overall Carnegie felt that the system worked to society's net benefit.

In order to properly evaluate these claims, you should first understand how evolution works, and how the underlying principle of natural selection does -- and more importantly does not -- map onto human social and economic systems. A full discussion of this is off topic, but I have provided links that should help out.

  • 1
    According to Wikipedia, "survival of the fittest" was coined by Herbert Spencer to describe the mechanism of natural selection formulated by Darwin: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Survival_of_the_fittest – apadana May 4 at 14:56
  • 1
    @Arham I guess I've been misinformed, then. Either way, Carnegie's use of the term likely reflects his belief in Social Darwinism. – Andrew May 4 at 16:04

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.