0

Which one is correct?

  1. I requested the police to permit me to enter the house.

  2. I requested permitting me to enter the house from the police.

  3. I requested to permit me to enter the house.

  4. I requested it from the police permitting me to enter the house from the police.

  5. I requested it from the police to permit me to enter the house.

I think 1,3,5 are correct, but only 2 and 4 barely make sense. I want to know the reason why if there's something wrong. Personally, I guess such a sentence structure like 2 as "request gerund from object" should be avoidable as people can misunderstand "from" as modifying "gerund" in meaning.

2

Of these, only #1 is fully correct.

"I requested" should usually be followed by who you are making the request of, or by what you are requesting. Often both are specified.

  • I requested John to help Jane (who= John, what=to help Jane)
  • I requested access to the computer. (what=access to the computer)

When a "what" is specified, it should usually be a noun or noun phrase

In #2

I requested permitting me to enter the house from the police.

"permitting me" is not a noun phrase nor does it function as one.

In #3

I requested to permit me to enter the house

there needs to be a {who} before the "to"

I requested Jack to permit me to enter the house

In #4

I requested it from the police permitting me to enter the house from the police.

"permitting" does not work in this context. One might say

  • I requested permission from the police for me to enter the house.
  • I needed permission to enter the house. I requested it from the police.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.