0

In Oxford Advanced Learner's Dictionary, the first definition of the word dialogue is as follows.

conversations in a book, play, or film/movie

In that specific dictionary, the phrase, a book, play, or film/movie is used a lot to describe many words' definitions.

As it seems that a book, play, or film/movie all share some quality in their nature, I've thought that the phrase can be substituted by other expressions.

What I came up with are as follows.

  1. conversations in art
  2. conversations in a piece of art or literature
  3. conversations in a produced content with imaginary characters in it

I would like to ask you how correct those are and ask for your guides.

1

Your suggestion are close, but might be misleading to a native speaker. Art, on its own, most usually means painting, drawing, sculpture and similar -- things which don't have dialogue. ("Conversations in art" could easily be understood as meaning Picasso and Matisse "conversing" through their paintings.) Produced content would not have a specific meaning without more context.

To includes novels, films and plays we would be much more likely to say

  • ... in a work of fiction
  • ... in any kind of fiction

You'll notice your original definition includes "book", which doesn't necessarily mean a work of fiction -- many biographies have dialogue in them.

  • Thank you very much for the detailed answer. And I understood the use of the word fiction would be very useful. Then how about using in a production or in a fictional production? I think a production might be also as abstract as produced content, but I, also, would like to know if there is any difference between in a production and in produced content there. I am sorry for asking you so much. – Smart Humanism May 22 at 6:35
0

The alternatives you have suggested are too abstract. One definition of "dialog" IS a conversation within the context of a book, play, or movie. That is very clear. The other three phrases are not as easily understood. Always strive for clarity, not ambiguity.

  • Thank you for such good advice and answering. – Smart Humanism May 22 at 5:31

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.