0

I searched for "or even like taking a" on Google, and I got results like these:

Sometimes that work looks a lot like staring blankly at the page, or even like taking a long walk with the dog.

The word ethics can sometimes seem overly philosophical, or even like taking a moral high ground.

Grammarly's blog states that you should add a comma before or if what follows is an independent clause. But as you can see in the examples, what follows aren't independent clauses (almost every result has a comma).

Why was a comma added in these examples?

Note: Because of this, I'm not sure whether to add a comma here:

He didn't feel dirty, or even like taking a shower.

  • I think coordinators like but and or are usually preceded by a comma. – Cardinal May 23 at 6:19
2

I think the commas are there simply because the writers of those examples did not agree with the guidelines Grammarly cites. And to be frank, I’m with those writers. I probably overuse commas, but (see!) I think my readers appreciate the assistance they provide if reading the material allowed. The pause implied by a comma can help the reader break longer, more complex sentences into more easily manageable chunks.

And that applies to your own example. I prefer your:

He didn’t feel dirty, or even like taking a shower.

over (your implied):

He didn’t feel dirty or even like taking a shower.

Bottom line here is that if it’s not negatively impacting comprehension or meaning, including nuance and the like, and may even be enhancing those things, then this is more a matter of style than of hard and fast rules.

2

I agree with tkp.

Essentially, I add commons either where you're technically meant to, or just where I might take a brief pause/breath (when I read the sentence out loud).

The sentences above would technically be correct without the commas, but it feels correct to have a pause at this point in the sentence to make the second part stand out. The author is making a point, in my opinion.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.