1

As far as I know, when two things happen at the same time, I can combine them with using participles.

Such as :

Kate is in the kitchen and she is making coffee.

to

Kate is in the kitchen making coffee.

Is using "being" okay in reduced "to be" phrases? I mean are those sentences below grammatically okay?

1- I sat there, still waiting, being worried that she would never arrive. (... and I was worried ...)

2- I was preaparing the food , my friends being sick of waiting. (I was preparing the food and my friends were sick of waiting)

3- Being shocked by his death, I passed out. (When I was shocked by his death...)

4- The word “book” has a double meaning , the noun form being “ a set of pages inside a cover”, while the verb form is "to arrange to have a seat etc. at a particular time in the future"

Can I omit the "being" in my examples?

1'- I sat there, still waiting, worried that she would never arrive.

2'- I was preaparing the food , my friends sick of waiting.

3'- Shocked by his death, I passed out

4'- The word “book” has a double meaning , the noun form “ a set of pages inside a cover”.

  • A similar post for anyone interested: ell.stackexchange.com/questions/209072/… – Cardinal Jun 8 at 17:27
  • You can remove being from 1 and 3, but not 2 and 4. – windblade Jun 8 at 21:59
  • @windblade Could you describe the reason in detail? – Talha Özden Jun 8 at 22:05
  • I think it's that "being" can be omitted from the beginning of a phrase, but not from the middle of a phrase. – windblade Jun 8 at 22:18
  • @windblade Hi. You said we can't omit the "being" in 2 and 4 but I see constructions of absoluete phrases and they omit "being". For example : "Six banks were robbed in three weeks, the undermanned police force (being) helpless to intervene." – Talha Özden Jun 17 at 11:14
0

Yes, I would say you can remove being from all four, but some may require an additional verb. Like for the second one, I might say, 'my friends were sick of waiting.' Choosing were as the plural past tense to match was in the first half of your sentence.

Being in my mind, if I use it as a verb at all, it's like referring to the act of /state of being or used as a noun.For example:

a human being or Being constantly late is not a good habit.

I actually can't think of any examples were I would use being except at the beginning of a sentence. In colloquial speech, you might hear someone say, 'I don't know why he's being so crazy' to mean, 'acting so crazy' or 'is so crazy'. But it isn't formally grammatically correct, I don't think.

  • But what I am trying to do is omit some verbs to produce a compound sentence by using participle clauses. For example: I was preaparing the food + in the meantime my friends were sick of waiting. = I was preaparing the food, my friends (being) sick of waiting. I mean if I use "were" here I don't produce a compound sentence here. This is just the opposite of what I am trying to do. – Talha Özden Jun 17 at 11:24
  • Gotcha. You could say, 'Waiting for me to finish cooking, my friends were getting tired of waiting.' That's a participle clause, I think. @TalhaÖzden – EmKhay Jun 17 at 11:27
  • Yes this one works. But my question here is about omitting "being" . :) "I was preaparing the food, my friends (being) sick of waiting." Can I omit the "being" ? because I have seen sentences that omit "being" such as : "Six banks were robbed in three weeks, the undermanned police force (being) helpless to intervene." – Talha Özden Jun 17 at 11:28
  • I answered that, I thought. You should omit 'being' it sounds weird in all of the sentences, I think. As a native American speaker. – EmKhay Jun 17 at 11:30
  • But you said you may require an additional verb instead of "being" ? Can I omit "being" in these examples and leave them as they are? – Talha Özden Jun 17 at 11:32

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.