I needed 10 watches but I realised that I had only 9. So what should be used:

1.) I am out one watch.

2.) I am one watch out.

3.) I am one watch short.

4.) I am short on one watch.

And if we're talking about a person:

1.) We're one player short.

2.) We're short on one player.

3.) We're out one player.

4.) We're one player out.

So what sounds natural #1,#2,#3 or #4 in both the contexts?


I am out one watch.

This doesn't fit your situation; I might use this if someone got into my gym locker and stole my watch.

I am one watch short.
I am short one watch.

Both of these work for the situation you describe (notice that I removed the "on" from #4).

Your #2 sounds more awkward than idiomatic.

Likewise, if we needed nine players for a baseball team, and we only had eight, we could say either one of these:

We're one player short.
We're short one player.

However, the phrase:

We're out one player

would make more sense if a player was on the team but then couldn't play for some reason (perhaps due to injury, or a red card).

| improve this answer | |

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.