0

Which of the following sentences is correct or more idiomatic for comparison between two things:

  1. The AUC (the area under curve) for the model A is greater than of the model B
  2. The AUC (the area under curve) for the model A is greater than for the model B
  3. The AUC (the area under curve) for the model A is greater than of that for the model B
  4. The AUC (the area under curve) of the model A is greater than of the model B
  5. The AUC (the area under curve) of the model A is greater than the model B

I feel the third one is more precise. However, I wonder if the first and second also are idiomatic and convey the desired meaning.

enter image description here

3

Either "for" or "of" is fine, just use the same preposition for both. It's fine not to repeat the preposition, as in your fifth example, but this is a style choice. "Of that for", in your third example is incorrect (or at least awkward).

Personally, I wouldn't use "the", since these are the names of the models:

The AUC of Model A is greater than that of Model B.

Notice I use "that of Model B". This is because I feel it's good style to compare "like to like", especially in a scientific publication. Other people might think shorter is better:

The AUC of Model A is greater than (of) Model B.

Again, this is about writing style, not grammar.

  • I'm a bit confused with the last sentence you put. Could you please explicitly write which one is the best one. I assume you mean the fifth one as "The AUC of Model A is greater than Model B" is the best. – Ahmad Jun 13 at 17:29

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.