1

So I'm reading the news and it says, "Three Americans have been found dead at one resort". Why is it "have been" and not were?

1
  • Because it's very recent. Take a look at our sister site, ELL. Commented Jun 6, 2019 at 4:12

3 Answers 3

3

While reporting news, "have been" is generally preferred to "were". One of the reasons for this is to indicate that this event happened in the recent past.

1

It is possible to use "were" but then you would add a time in the recent past when they were found, like "this morning" or "at 2 o'clock", for example. Present perfect also emphasizes the effect the discovery has on the present.

-2

I'm assuming the bodies were found at different times, since a present perfect tense suggests a continuity of action in the past, whereas a simple past tense describes an event that occurred and ended at a particular time.

Or perhaps it is just the writer being superfluous.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .