2

Does it make sense when two articles are used, for example “An exactly the same”? If the former conveys inspecific/abstract item, then what does the latter do?

5

You're asking if we use the phrase: An exactly the same?

Not normally. It's not generally grammatical to use an article to introduce an adverb (exactly), nor to use two articles to introduce a noun (same).

But it could be used for some kind of special effect, as could almost any string of words. A context might be that two people see a woman. One says she's the same woman they saw on the TV news because she robbed a bank:

A: I'm telling you, she's a completely different woman!
B: And I'm telling you: she's an exactly-the-same woman. Let's catch her!

That's something I can cook up in my imagination as possible. But whether or not it's grammatical depends on a careful definition of grammar.

1
  • Hmm, thanks. I like English because it is so much more free/liberal then Russian :) I mean in Russian no one would even imagine that grammar can be defined (carefully or not). It just exists (and it's very strict) :) Jul 9 '19 at 4:19

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .