Does it make sense when two articles are used, for example “An exactly the same”? If the former conveys inspecific/abstract item, then what does the latter do?


You're asking if we use the phrase: An exactly the same?

Not normally. It's not generally grammatical to use an article to introduce an adverb (exactly), nor to use two articles to introduce a noun (same).

But it could be used for some kind of special effect, as could almost any string of words. A context might be that two people see a woman. One says she's the same woman they saw on the TV news because she robbed a bank:

A: I'm telling you, she's a completely different woman!
B: And I'm telling you: she's an exactly-the-same woman. Let's catch her!

That's something I can cook up in my imagination as possible. But whether or not it's grammatical depends on a careful definition of grammar.

  • Hmm, thanks. I like English because it is so much more free/liberal then Russian :) I mean in Russian no one would even imagine that grammar can be defined (carefully or not). It just exists (and it's very strict) :) – Nurbol Alpysbayev Jul 9 '19 at 4:19

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.