0

A website lists some activities offered in a photography tour, then adds Not only that, but there's more.

... [S]unset and moon rise occur at the perfect time and will allow us to photograph New York Harbor during the day and the New York skyline at sunset, the blue hour and at night from the incredible vantage point of Liberty State Park and the Empty Sky Memorial. Not only that, but there’s more. There will be a full moon rising shortly after sunset... .

http://www.adventures-in-photography.com/meetup/photograph-ny-harbor-by-boat-the-statue-of-liberty-the-ship-graveyard-and-more-3/

Is the sentence grammatical or generally acceptable?

I think but should introduce a contradicting idea, but it doesn't do that here. I think the but should be removed and replaced with a comma or a dot. Do you agree? Why?

1
  • You should share some of the examples you found when you searched on Google. Saying "it seems like a few people use it, but it doesn't really sound grammatical" isn't really fair to the community. We have no idea how the phrase is being used, or how it was worded exactly, or whether you found it in places that were professionally written by journalists vs carelessly written by amateur bloggers. – J.R. Jul 11 '19 at 1:08
1

But, in such constructions, does introduce a contrast.

It introduces a contrast with a supposed idea that there is only that.

Although the literal statement is negated ([there is] not only that), the negation implies the idea that someone believes or may believe that there is only that.

The contrast is between what may have been thought or assumed (there's only that) and what's actually the case (there's more).

Logic in language is often obscure like this. English isn't math or a programming language! It wasn't created by conscious design.

1
  • 3
    The OP's phrase looks like a variant of the more ubiquitous But wait, there's more! – J.R. Jul 11 '19 at 11:37

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.