1

a) Why are you trying so hard?

b) Why you're trying so hard?

Is you're (b) an acceptable contraction form of are you (a) when I want to keep the sentence in a question form?

Is there another way to contract (this) question in English?

1

One can indeed use a contraction in question:

Why don't you do it today?

But "you're" is a contraction of "you are" not of "are you " so it does not work in sentence b) from the question, which expands to:

Why you are trying so hard?

which is not really grammatical, and certainly does not carry the same meaning as sentence a).

"you're" can be used in a question in any case that "you are" can be. For example:

You're not going to leave early, are you?

1

you're is generally a contraction of "you are", so saying "why you are trying so hard?" would not sound totally correct in this instance. In general though there's no particular reason to not use a contraction in a question.

However, if formulated slightly differently it would sound idiomatic. Consider "You have to ask yourself why you're trying so hard".

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.