0

What is the correct:

As physics know today or As physics knows today?

I would be inclined to use the first one, but isn't physics the science name, like a single not plural entity?

I am relating to the word semantics. The ending s on that word is not technically, a plural, or is a plural that was incorporated to form a singular word. Isn't it?

So, what do you think?

As physics know today or As physics knows today?

1

The form

As physics knows today, ...

Is grammatically correct. "Physics" is the name of a single science or field of study, and so is singular, and takes singular forms.

However, this construction requires personifying "physics" which as a field of study, cannot literally 'know" anything. This is also not a very usual construction.

In my view, it would would be better to say something like

  • The consensus among physicists today is ...
  • Today, physicists generally believe ...
  • The current understanding of physics is ...
  • Current theories of physics state ...
  • Today, physics theories hold that ...
  • The current view in physics is ...
  • brilliant explanation. That construction is valid in my natural language but in English that was bothering me as wrong. THANKS! – SpaceDog Aug 23 at 6:43
1

More context and detail about what you're trying to say would be helpful (like some examples of complete sentences). But I suggest:

As physicists (know / have learned / are aware), ...

Possession of knowledge is a trait more commonly attributed to living things than to fields of study.

That said, physics is a singular noun, despite the "s." The same is true for mathematics, but not for the physical sciences.

You can attribute human traits to non-living things if you know what you're doing. This process is called anthropomorphism, but I think that is beyond the scope of this answer.

  • brilliant explanation. That construction is valid in my natural language but in English that was bothering me as wrong. THANKS! – SpaceDog Aug 23 at 6:43

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.