1

What is the difference between the two sentences below:

They did it for the nicest reasons
They did it for the nicest of reasons

from the meaning perspective?

Note: I see that someone downgraded the question without even the courtesy of telling why. Please tell so we can learn. Note that we are not native speakers.

  • A similar phrase is “best intentions/best of intentions” – thehole Sep 9 at 23:58
2

I am a native UK English speaker and have spent a few minutes trying to figure out the difference between the two phrasings. In an informal situation, such as a simple conversation I don't think we would expend effort to select one or the other; both imply a very positive motivation.

If we were delivering a formal speech or were producing a written document we might note that

nicest reasons

is plural, implying that there were more than one reasons for the action. Whereas

nicest of reasons

allows for there being a single motivation. I do think that the phrase does not exclude there being multiple nicest of reasons.

I suspect that the we would actually select one phrase or the other based on our sense of style and rhythm. To my ears "nicest of reasons" seems, um, nicer. I had thought it was actually more idiomatic too, but I can find no evidence for that; "nicest of reasons" seems not be found by Google's ngram.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.