0

I asked a question just now, where I would like discuss if 21 is in some sense ideal.

Mathematically, is 21 ideal for Blackjack in some sense?

The "mathematically" qualifier is opposed to other perspective, such as "historically", this post explains why Blackjack choose 21 as the winner point from the historical perspective. And I would like to discuss it from the mathematical perspective.

Is this expression in question clear and idiomatic?

  • Did you delete your question? The link seems broken. – J.R. Sep 21 at 12:11
1

It's not terrible, but in response to your phrasing, none of the following questions is entirely unreasonable (although one or two hint that the questioner -- in this case me -- may be being a bit of a pedantic pain in the bum :-) :

What do you mean by "ideal"?

When you say "21", are you referring to the total of the cards in a hand, or the number of players?

Or does "21" refer to the family of card games of which Blackjack is a member?

Why the "mathematically" qualifier? As opposed to what?

And so given that I'd say there is room for improvement, at least in terms of clarity. One alternative that I think makes the above questions redundant might be:

In Blackjack, is there any sense in which a hand of 21 is the ideal?

I'm still using that vague "ideal", but I think my overall form, reducing as it does subtle cognitive dissonance and uncertainty I feel yours had, leaves little or no doubt that "ideal" means something like "that which is most likely to win".

But this is all very nuanced stuff. No one could seriously criticize your version without deserving a gentle slap around the ear-hole.

  • Thanks a lot! The "mathematically" qualifier is opposed to other perspective, such as "historically", this post explains why Blackjack choose 21 as the winner point from the historical perspective. And I would like to discuss it from the mathematical perspective. – fu DL Sep 21 at 8:08
  • Ah, right. Makes sense. – tkp Sep 21 at 18:19
  • So, how to express the whole thing in a clear and condensed way? I guess the OP right now is a little bit redundant. – fu DL Sep 22 at 0:47

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.