As you said or as you say?
As you mentioned or as you mention?
As he described or as he describes?

Which are correct?
If I understand correctly, the formers are correct.

Why use past tense here?

  • As you said or as you say? > As you said
  • As you mentioned or as you mention? > As you mentioned
  • As he described or as he describes? > As he described

When you are constructing a sentence such as the above, you must always use the verb in the past tense form. This is because we are usually talking about an event that has already happened.

  • As you said earlier, we should bring a packed lunch.
  • As he mentioned earlier in his speech, we all need to vote.

However, if, for example, the person in question was still saying/mentioning/describing the thing, then you could use the present form or the present continuous form:

  • As you are (currently) saying.
  • As you are (currently) mentioning.
  • As you are (currently) describing.

Furtherly, I feel that another situation in which it would be correct to use 'as you say' etc would be if you were talking about what someone does customarily. For example:

  • Aluminium, or as you say aluminum, is a highly malleable metal. In this case we are comparing someone's accent or spelling to that of the person who is speaking.
| improve this answer | |
  • 1
    Thanks a lot ! ;D – Rick Sep 23 '19 at 8:22
  • upvoted. "As you say" can also refer to an idiom ("As they say in French, c'est la vie!) or, as was (at least) hinted at in this answer, a regular saying: "As the Queen says, 'We are not amused.'" – michael Apr 29 at 1:12

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.