0

In my mother language (Portuguese) , these sentences:

The house looks twice as big as it did in the street.

I'll go as quickly as I can

They mean, when they are translated, this:

The house looks bigger than it did in the street

I'll go faster that I can.

Are those sentences equal in meaning? Because, comparative of equality means that the two itens are equal, not more than the other.

Or, maybe those 2 sentences (using Comparative of Equality)ate just an exception and I can use both of these structures to say the same thing (One this is more than the other).

  • You're ignoring the crucial word "twice". "Twice as X as Y" means something very different from "as X as Y". – Colin Fine Sep 28 at 20:20
  • I didn't understand you comment that much. Could you explain a little bit further? Because, in my first example, I used the word "twice". I would like to know if I can use either comparative of equality or superiority to say the same thing in these cases. – Jason O'Neil Sep 28 at 20:30
  • See Michael Paul's answer. – Colin Fine Sep 28 at 22:36
1

I doubt that the second sentence translates to “faster”, because “as fast as I can” means at my maximum speed. The first sentence uses the word twice, as pointed out by Colin Fine, so it is also a “Comparative of Equality” as you call it, but it compares the original size to double the size. So actually the first translation is also not accurate: a = 2b does not mean the same thing as a > b

In other words: a sentence with the structure

A is as B as C

always means: B is equal for A and C

But beware of optional modifiers like twice, half, n times. These can be between is and as, like for example:

A is 7.3 times as rich as C

which means exactly this: The wealth (richness) of A is exactly 7.3 times the wealth of C.

Edit: I've thought of more modifiers: "at least", "at most", "nearly", "hardly", "likely", "certainly", “not” and I'm sure many adverbs would be able to fill this spot depending on context. Example:

A is at least as good as B for the job.

Meaning A is equally good or better, compared to B, analogous to ≥

Not all of these have obvious counterparts in mathematical notation, I wouldn’t know how to write “nearly”, but the starting point is always equality.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.